Jimma Times logo
 
 
 Web  Jimma Times 
Reader Login
Username:
Password:
 Save Login?
Free Sign-up
Forgot Password?
Reader Control Panel
 
 
 
Orthodox church biggest noise polluter in Ethiopia [Opinion]
Opinion| By Tony Hickey

Over the last decade, Addis Abeba has improved beyond recognition, with a developed road network, more efficient garbage disposal and urban cleaning systems, better connectivity (although there is still a long way to go), more modern buildings, and improved services in terms of hotels, shops, and restaurants. Only in one respect has no progress been made - noise pollution. Rather, it has gone backwards, the problem has become worse.

When it comes to noise, the biggest polluters are the religious institutions, and the biggest offender is, by far, the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. I know people also complain about being woken up at 5:00am by the mosques’ call to prayer, but at least we can get back to sleep afterwards, whereas once the Orthodox Church kicks off at 4:30am, it will keep going for the next five hours.

Then there are the sermons, particularly in the evenings, when children might be doing homework, or adults unwinding after a day’s work. Generally, the preferred mode of delivery is an angry, hectoring rant.

“It is not about praising God, but about scolding people,” an elderly (Orthodox) neighbour once remarked to me.

Religious noise pollution, delivered by ever more powerful speakers and sound systems, is the elephant in the room. No one, with the exception of a few journalists (special mention here to Solomon Shumiye, of “Shai Bunna”), wants to acknowledge it openly. The irony is that virtually everyone, even the devout Orthodox, are against it. I have never met someone who said, “Yes, it is great to be woken up and kept awake all night by religious loudspeakers!”

Bring up the topic at any gathering, and everyone has a tale to tell of how they suffer from it. Yet, ask them why they do not complain, and they look at you as if you were crazy. Most citizens, including foreigners, whether residents, tourists, businesspeople, or investors say, “Enough is enough! It is time the government did something about this!”

Parliament passed the noise pollution problem to the Ethiopian Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), asking it to come up with a policy and guidelines appropriate to the Ethiopian context (code for “get the religious institutions to cut down the noise from their loudspeakers.”) However, the EPA does not want to take on the churches and mosques, so nothing has happened.

The excuse for inaction is usually, “we know it is a problem, but there are more important things to tackle, such as poverty reduction and the struggle for development.” This is on a par with saying, “we should not try to enforce the wearing of seatbelts until we have eradicated female genital mutilation.” Tackling one does not preclude tackling the other; governments always engage in multitasking.

Another excuse is, “now is not the right time to take on the churches and mosques.” Actually, there could not be a better time, as the Ethiopian Peoples’ Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) has just won overwhelmingly at the polls, and has the clear authority to tell the religious institutions that it is instituting noise regulations to protect the health and wellbeing of citizens. This would be in line with international norms, and particularly in the case of Addis Abeba, in keeping with its status as the diplomatic capital of Africa.

Noise pollution is anti development. It creates no go zones around churches for hotel and property developers; damages the business of existing hotels; lowers the value of property in the worst affected areas; and sends out a totally false message to foreign visitors, whether tourists or investors, that Ethiopians are religious fanatics.

Tourists who had driven down to Ethiopia through Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Sudan told me they had never experienced anything like Ethiopia on a Sunday morning where they had been kept awake all night.

Noise damages people’s health. It is scientifically acknowledged to cause stress, cardiac problems, and headaches. To perform properly, whether at work or at school, people need a proper night’s sleep, the lack of which can be life threatening in some professions.

A prominent neurosurgeon once told of how he went into the operating theatre at 6:00am one morning, totally exhausted, having been kept awake all night by church loudspeakers. Think of what not being fully alert after a good night’s sleep means for a bus driver with 50 passengers, or the pilot of a plane.

Noise pollution is also anti peace. Ethiopia rightly prides itself on the harmony that has long existed among followers of different faiths in the country. That harmony is now threatened, as events over the last decade in Mekele, Awassa, Jimma, and other places bear witness - with people killed, and places of worship torched. Here in Addis Abeba, there have been several clashes - one in the Bole Michael area between Muslims and Pentecostals necessitated the intervention of the Federal Police.

The spark for these clashes has always been noise. Forcing people, within a radius of several square kilometres, to listen to a religious service for several hours that many may not subscribe to, and waking them up in the process, does not show respect for other faiths, but contempt. It is an abuse of the religious freedom afforded to the various religions in the country by the victory of the EPRDF over the Derg.

Ethiopia’s enemies (hint, think of countries beginning with the letter “E”), must be happy with this development, threatening as it does the very social fabric of the nation, and have probably been donating loudspeaker systems to religious institutions around the country.

The solution to this problem can only come from the federal government, and from the EPRDF as the ruling party. This responsibility should not be handed down to some other agency or city administration which will only sit on its hands and prevaricate. Clear instructions must be given.

Speakers in places of worship should be directed into the compound of the institution in question, not outwards. The decibel output should not exceed levels dangerous to public health, and at night, should not be sufficiently loud to wake people who live in the area, up. Should this happen, there can only be winners, not losers. Harmony can be restored, followers of different faiths can live side by side, their beliefs a matter of personal commitment, not something rammed down their neighbours’ throats or ears.

Christianity and Islam in Ethiopia have survived and flourished without loudspeakers for 1,660 and 1,370 years, respectively - from the date of their appearance in the country to the fall of the Derg. In this case, as Ethiopia enters its third millennium, there are clear lessons to be learned from the past.

Post A Comment
Comments 7 comments for this article
Added: August 18, 2010. 07:47 PM GMT
Tony you settled made good money by vertue of the churches you are out to blem.You had wonderfull years in Ethiopia thanks to the EPRDF.Do you think Ethiopia is fineshed no one to stop you trying to undermine our culture becouse you made good money out of it for the last 19 years as orignal.There is time for all things do not be fullish people know your type of people....
Anonymous
Added: August 18, 2010. 09:57 PM GMT
just to say something
The writer looks like a missionary.And offcourse.
Anonymous
Added: August 19, 2010. 01:44 AM GMT
Anonymous
Added: September 05, 2010. 02:56 PM GMT
Listening to word of God is not being polluted
Hey Tony. Thanks for ur toxic comment. Religion is part of our identity. The sound we listen is food for our soul. It is not pollutant .It is the word of God. Rather it clears the polluted world. Do u know how the wall of Jericho was collapsed? It is by blowing big horns. We beleive that we should listen to the word of God anywhere in our ouse, workplace and etc. That is why we use big loud speakers. I wonder why u are not willing to mention the restaurants, music houses with big loud speaker ? Is it only in the morning that mosques are sounding? of course not. Why dont u mention the horn from different cars who are actually pollutants.
Your focus is only on Ethiopian Orthodox church and protestants churches . Or christianity in short .Why do u focus on christianity only? Why? I can see ur hidden mission .Our enemies think that it is the time to hammer Christianity in Ethiopia since our government is irresponsible and is pressuring churches. Somalians and other islamist extrimists are also grudging and vowing to destroy christianity .The struggle to dismantle christianity in our country is being streamed in different ways , among which this type is one .Probably u are one part of them , a wolf in a sheep skin.


He who hates to listen word of God is demon by the way. listening to word of God is not being polluted and word of God isnot pollutant . It is being blessed rather.
No body touched ur boarder. Dont knock our door and insult us with offensive languages . U can plug ear phones and listen to laddy gagas or snoopy dogs music( i am sur that wont pollute u) . that is ur right, but u have no authority to insult our church, our religion.
religious teaching is not pollutant u moron
Anonymous
Added: September 06, 2010. 08:40 PM GMT
Anonymous
Added: January 01, 2011. 09:42 PM GMT
Who can stop these idiots
To begin with, I am an Orthodox Christian.
I was in Addis lately, after being abroad for several years, and I was very excited about my vacation there. But after the second night some noise woke me up at three in the morning. That intoralable noise came from a loudspeaker of a brand new church (I heard somebody found that church some three and half years ago) not far from my parents' place. To be precise, it is the Beza-Kidanemihret Church at Kebena. I had to get dressed and go away. Later that day I discussed the matter with some neighbours, everyone of them said they were disturbed, but no one dared complain. One landlord said that he lost tenants because of the noise. After a second sleepless night two days later, I started looking for a quiter place (a hotel or a motel...), my family pleaded with me to stay, and I had to obey. Without exaggeration, the noise kept harassing me every second day for six weeks. I had plans to do some decorative and reparatory work on our house, but after some deliberation we decided it is better to move out of the area. The problem is, you have no guarantee that a noisy church or a mosque would not get there after you moved in.
PS: I had made a some pictures in and around the church at three and four in the morning, there were only a couple of beggars in and around the church. The noise was audible as far as Kebena-bridge (more than a kilometer away from the church). I tried to speak with the head priest about the situation, but he just seemed to wonder about my audacity to talk about a church matter. I am sure, he can sleep any time of the day, while most of his victimes have to go to school or work.
Werner2010
Added: July 15, 2011. 04:06 AM GMT
whole
k may be it is a polusion but what ever it comes the problrm lies in the science why do scientists creat speakers is that not for this purpose. i accept that but what ever people hear some thing that they don't like or commited to they complain. what did you say those other churchs who speak loudlyby using different specialized speakers. they even locaed every where at least in 1km far distance or in every compounds. the distance between two ethiopian churches is so far there fore they may not disturb as compaired to other religous institutions.

an other point is that the time 5 oclock some thing.. the time is a begging of ethiopian orthodox church cermony called "kidase" there fore in prenciple it is expected that every followers should be in church at that time there for they need to be awake and there is a ring .thanks to technology it gives us speaker too. there fore what ever your suggestion is there is always thanks for GODsince we are createdfor that
miss t